Whether living in an RV, a van, or a tiny home, finding the best toilet for your space and lifestyle is essential. Composting toilets have gained popularity due to their environmental benefits, but before you make the switch, there are some crucial factors to consider.
Below, we’ll explore five reasons why composting toilets may not be the correct choice for your tiny space. Read on as we break down everything you need to know about composting toilets, from cost and maintenance considerations to their size.
What Is a Composting Toilet?
A composting toilet is a way to transform human waste into compost material that you can use in gardens and outdoor areas. It uses natural composting processes like temperature and microbes to break down solid waste into compost over time.
It is also an incredibly efficient way of treating sewage, requiring no external water and little energy to operate.
Furthermore, composting toilets have other environmental benefits, like reduced water pollution, improved rural sanitation solutions, and lower methane emissions since they don’t require flushing with fresh water after every use.
Why Do People Use Composting Toilets?
Composting toilets are becoming increasingly popular among those looking to limit their environmental impact. By composting our waste instead of flushing it, we can cut back on traditional sewage treatment methods and compost our waste.
Composting toilets usually require less energy, water, and space than traditional flush toilets. Overall, they are a more sustainable solution.
Additionally, composting toilets produce far less waste in comparison to flush models. Output from composting toilets is often safe for gardening or agricultural use.
HOT TIP
Before you install a composting toilet, find out Are Composting Toilets Dangerous?
5 Reasons to Avoid Composting Toilets
Composting toilets provide an eco-friendly and water-conserving solution for toilet waste, but don’t jump on the composting bandwagon yet. While composting toilets are excellent for some, a few caveats exist before investing in one.
1. They’re Expensive
The first reason to avoid composting toilets is their price. Nature’s Head composting toilets are one of the more popular options, but like many others, they cost $1,000 or more. That price does not include installation.
There is also the ongoing expense of composting medium and liners to consider. In comparison to basic traditional types of plumbing systems, composting toilets don’t make economic sense.
2. They Use Energy
It’s no surprise that composting toilets need energy. After all, most modern devices need electricity to run, and composting toilets are no exception. They use an electrical fan to move the waste through the vessel and speed up the composting process.
3. They Can Get Bugs
Another reason to avoid composting toilets is that they can attract bugs. Composting toilets use natural processes like temperature and microbes to break down solid waste into compost over time. This process can attract pests like flies, cockroaches, and other insects.
The heat generated during the composting process may also create a favorable environment for some bacteria or fungi that could harm humans when inhaled or ingested.
For these reasons, it’s crucial to take appropriate measures like using insecticides and following a regular cleaning routine to reduce the risk of bug infestations.
4. They’re a Pain to Clean
Composting toilets can also be challenging to clean. Using natural processes like temperature and microbes to break down solid waste into compost can produce an unpleasant smell if you don’t properly manage it.
Additionally, you must regularly remove the organic matter these systems produce. Otherwise, they won’t continue functioning as intended. This requires a certain level of maintenance that many people may find too tedious or time-consuming.
5. They’re Big
Lastly, many people fail to consider that composting toilets can be relatively bulky and take up a lot of space. This is especially true for those living in vans, RVs, or tiny homes where space is at a premium.
Composting toilets typically require larger vessels than standard plumbing systems. They’re not always the best choice if you want to save space.
Additionally, composting toilets need a power source nearby to function correctly. This need for power could limit the area in which they could fit.
HOT TIP
No toilet? No problem! Find out How Do Campers Use the Bathroom Off-Grid?
What Are Alternatives to a Composting Toilet?
Composting toilets are a popular choice for RVs and tiny homes, but they’re not the only eco-friendly option available.
One alternative is a dry flush toilet, which uses a small amount of water to create an odor barrier and seal waste in a disposable bag. This type of toilet is straightforward to install and maintain. It’s ideal for those who don’t want to deal with the hassle of composting or storing waste.
Another option is an incinerating toilet, which uses electricity or propane to burn waste into ash. While this may sound like an extreme solution, incinerating toilets are safe and efficient, producing no harmful emissions or odors. They’re also convenient and require minimal maintenance, making them an excellent choice for a hassle-free toilet solution.
Should You Avoid a Composting Toilet?
Composting toilets may be eco-friendly and water-conserving, but they can also be challenging to clean, take up space, and require a nearby power source. It’s crucial to consider whether you might be better off avoiding a composting toilet and considering other options.
Ultimately it’s best to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully so you can find one that best suits your needs while helping conserve resources.
Would you use a composting toilet? Tell us your thoughts in the comments!
If You Love RVing, You Need to Stay Informed
Don’t rely on biased RV industry news sources to keep you informed with RVing news.
Stick with Nomadic News. We publish daily articles and breaking stories that matter to your RV lifestyle.
